Drives Toyota RAV4
Wants 'Something just as safe for me and my dog.
It needs to have an automatic gearbox and four-wheel drive. Better fuel economy would be nice, too.'
What Car? recommends
If, like Sarah, you want our help to find your ideal car, just e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org with:
• A photo of yourself
• Your budget
• Your current car
• Your age
• Your annual mileage
• Other useful info
Subaru Impreza 2.0 R auto
Target Price £16,079
It doesn't have as much ground clearance as an SUV, but the Impreza does have four-wheel drive to help out on those slippery roads. This auto version is surprisingly frugal for a petrol – it'll do 34.4mpg.
Volkswagen Tiguan 2.0 TDI SE DSG, '08/08
Pricey when new, but a year-old Tiguan is a great buy. It's as good on Tarmac as many small hatches, and this 2.0-litre diesel version should manage almost 40mpg – even with the optional auto 'box.
Land Rover Freelander 2.2 TD4 GS auto, '07/07
It's miles ahead of the Tiguan when the road turns to mush, but fuel economy does take a hit from the Freelander's optional automatic gearbox – Sarah could expect a maximum of only 33.2mpg.