What Car? Car of the Year awards 2011 - Crossover contenders

Article 23 of 36 See all
  • 17 categories of awards
  • All the winning models featured here
  • What Car? Car of the Year 2011 revealed

What Car? Awards 2012 website

Best buy less than £15,000
Nissan Juke 1.6 Visia
List price £12,795
Target Price £12,101


It was always going to take a special car to beat last year’s price point winner, the Skoda Yeti 1.2 TSI S. The Nissan Juke is that car.

From its attention-grabbing exterior to the motorbike-inspired interior, there’s nothing else like it on the road. The petrol engine is surprisingly punchy for a 1.6, while the taut handling and communicative steering make the Juke fun when the road turns interesting.

It’s not the most practical car by any means, but it’s big enough for light family duties – and besides, your children will quickly forget any space issues when you drop them off at the school gates in the coolest car going. A bargain price, low running costs and loads of standard kit round off the Juke’s repertoire.

If you need more space, the Yeti is still a cracking car. It’s as practical as crossovers get for the money and it’s good to drive.

The cut-price Suzuki SX4, now with a more powerful petrol engine, is also worth a look.

Neither can beat the Juke for all-round appeal, though. Fresh, fun and funky, the Juke is a worthy winner.

Nissan Juke review


Performance
0-62mph 11.0sec Top speed 110mph
Running costs
Economy 44.1mpg CO2 147g/km
Insurance group 11

Best buy £15,000-£20,000
Peugeot 3008 1.6 THP 156 Sport
List price £19,145
Target Price £17,943


Competition has been red hot in this price point over the past year. First there was the restyled Nissan Qashqai, which added better refinement and more cabin storage to its existing talents of a silky ride, low price and generous kit list.

The Mitsubishi ASX also waded in with its punchy, economical diesel engine and roomy cabin. Then there were the Hyundai ix35 and Kia Sportage twins, mixing striking looks with family-friendly cabins and masses of equipment for the money.

Despite all the new rivals, the Peugeot 3008 takes the plaudits for a second year running. That’s not to say that Peugeot has rested on its laurels, though. A new petrol engine offers more power and better economy than the one in last year’s winner, while the classy cabin and smooth ride remain as impressive as ever.

It’s the Peugeot 3008's versatility that seals the deal, however. It has a spacious cabin and a large, well-shaped boot, and it’s quick and easy to convert from five-seat family car to two-seat removal van.

Peugeot 3008 review

Performance
0-62mph 8.9sec Top speed 125mph
Running costs
Economy 39.7mpg CO2 167g/km
Insurance group 20

Best buy more than £20,000
Volvo XC60 2.0 D3 DRIVe SE
List price £29,645
Target Price £27,405


To be honest, nothing got close to defeating the Volvo XC60. In the past year, the Toyota RAV4 gained a new, efficient front-wheel-drive powertrain and more equipment, while the sharp-handling Ford Kuga got uprated diesel engines.

Neither is a patch on the Volvo, though. Not even the classy and practical Volkswagen Tiguan got a look in.

The XC60 effortlessly combines the best bits of 4x4, MPV and family car in one package, mixing rugged looks and a high-up driving position with reasonable running costs.

Many MPVs could learn a lesson in versatility from the XC60, too. There’s masses of space front and rear, a big boot and plenty of thoughtful touches such as optional integrated child booster seats.

This front-wheel-drive DRIVe model will be a rare sight at fuel stations, thanks to a new 2.0-litre engine that uses even less fuel than the 2.4 in last year’s version. Its CO2 emissions are also impressively low.

The XC60 is a deserving winner at this price point for the second year running.

Volvo XC60 review

Performance
0-62mph 10.3sec Top speed 124mph
Running costs
Economy 47.9mpg CO2 154g/km
Insurance group 28

Tester's view
‘I love the fact that crossovers have the cool, chunky looks of a 4x4, while mixing the practicality of an MPV with the dynamics of a saloon car.

‘The showstopper for me this year has been the Nissan Juke. It looks like nothing else on sale at the moment, which is great. I also like the way it fits with my lifestyle: it easily copes with my daily motorway commute without costing too much in fuel or road tax, yet it’s large enough for taxi duties with friends and family at the weekend. It’s also fun to drive.

‘I’d quite happily take home either of the Juke’s two rivals here, too. The Volvo XC60 has acres of space in its posh, plush cabin, while our 2010 Car of the Year – the Peugeot 3008 – does everything you could possibly want a car to do, and does it perfectly.’
Rosie McMahon Assistant database editor
Rosie.McMahon@whatcar.com

Featured in this story

What Car? Car of the Year awards 2011 - Crossover winner

advertisement

Free car valuations

advertisement