JD Power Owner Satisfaction 2009 - MPVs 9-15
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 76.4%
Overall ranking: 78th=
The Volkswagen Touran's stuffy appearance, and high service and repair costs were to blame for the Touran's sharp dive out of last year's top 40.
Owners also failed to be impressed by the Touran's stereo/navigation system, either.
Otherwise, marks were mostly average – including those for reliability, vehicle performance, interior appeal and nearly all aspects of dealer service.
The few highlights were good all-round visibility and fuel economy.
10: Ford C-Max
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 76%
Overall ranking: 83rd=
Largely average marks for Ford's five-seat MPV were spoilt by inadequate interior storage and space, and disappointing fuel economy. The seats were also rated below average.
Only the reliability of the air-con scored top marks, but owners were pleased with the dependable engine, transmission and exterior electrical features. Low service and repair costs also scored high marks, as did the user-friendliness of the air-conditioning.
11: Renault Scenic
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 75.9%
Overall ranking: 85th
No real horror stories here, but owners weren't keen on the Scénic's engine and gearbox, nor the functionality or reliability of its air-con system. Its looks didn't go down well, either.
However, all aspects of reliability (apart from the air-conditioning system) scored average or above, and owners praised the Renault's roomy cabin, storage facilities and visibility from the driver's seat. Each aspect of the ownership costs and dealer service was given average marks.
12: Ford S-Max
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 75%
Overall ranking: 92nd
Reports of awful dealer service, poor visibility and worrying exterior quality helped contribute to a bottom-10 finish. That's a shame, because owners were otherwise mostly positive about the S-Max, rating its engine, gearbox and driveability well, along with its smart styling.
Only the Citroën Grand C4 Picasso scored higher marks for interior appeal, with respondents rating every area above average. However, ownership costs sealed the Ford's fate: insurance, fuel, and service or repair bills were too high.
13: Vauxhall Safira
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 74.9%
Overall ranking: 93rd
A similarly dire result to last year, with Zafira owners having a big moan about reliability and visibility. Mechanical problems were high on the list of gripes, but the biggest number of gremlins cropped up in the air-con and audio/sat-nav systems.
What's more, the seven-seat Vauxhall didn't have any redeeming features in the eyes of its drivers – the engine, gearbox, driving dynamics and dealer service fared best, but even these were graded as only average.
14: Mazda 5
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 74.5%
Overall ranking: 97th
This was a mixed bag, but overall a very disappointing finish for the 5. Running costs (fuel economy in particular) were slated by owners, as was mechanical reliability (but not the engine or gearbox). Drivers didn't approve of the driving dynamics or the car's performance, either.
Aside from some glitches in the audio/navigation system, the interior did at least retain some of Mazda's good reputation for robustness, with top marks awarded for air-con and seat reliability. However, owners were lukewarm about visibility and styling.
15: Ford Galaxy
Vehicle owner satisfaction score: 73.8%
Overall ranking: 99th
The Galaxy was worst of the MPVs and third bottom overall. So what went wrong for Ford's biggest MPV? Reliability, mainly – owners were damning about the interior, with large numbers of seat and audio/navigation system woes. Bodywork issues and exterior electrics were also a serious concern. When things did go wrong, Ford dealers were less than helpful – service was given a real kicking.
Owners also disliked the styling, driving dynamics, interior and insurance costs. In fact, they weren't particularly positive about anything.
How they rated:
Click the image, below, to view a larger version of how all the cars rated.
Featured in this story