For This can seat seven, and the mechanicals are pretty robust. The 1.9-litre diesel engine is the pick of the range, too, and you can fit the DSG semi-automatic gearbox for an extra £1500.
Against It’s a van with seats, and no amount of car-like plastics inside can disguise that. However, its seats are nowhere near as flexible as those in VW’s Touran. It’s not cheap, either.
Yes, the Caddy offers plenty of space and this is the better of its two engine options, but we’d advise you to try a Touran or Ford S-Max first.
VW Caddy Maxi Life is a seven-seat MPV brazen about its origins; it looks like a van with windows, and only comes with diesel engines.
Sure enough, the Caddy is big inside, and it will seat seven, but its seating system is more fiddly than regular MPVs’; you won’t enjoy taking out the third row of seats to increase boot space, for example, because it weighs five stone.
Two diesel engines are available, a 138bhp 2.0-litre unit and a 1.9-litre motor with 103bhp. We’d opt for the 1.9, since it’s considerably cheaper and comes with VW’s DSG twin-clutch gearbox.
As you might expect in an MPV with commercial-vehicle origins, both units are pretty noisy; there’s road noise, too, but the Caddy Maxi Life is capable of relatively swift and refined progress.
It’s more difficult to excuse the Caddy’s high price and relatively short list of safety kit, though; we’d look long and hard at VW’s bespoke MPV, the Touran, before talking Caddy prices with our local dealer.