Land Rover Defender
Sixty years old and still going strong, you gave the Defender a score nearly 12.5% higher than its rivals.
The Discovery was let down by its poor reliability, but it still got average marks.
So, what have whatcar.com users been saying about 4x4s and crossovers. Here's what you thought about the winning Land Rover Defender - and its unreliable sibling, the Discovery.
Do you agree? Have you say through whatcar.com's reader review section. Tell us about your own experiences.
The full results are here...
Your reader reviews...
This car is simply awesome off road!
'The engine and six-speed box are a great combination, too.'
Oliver Bambridge 90 2.4D XS Station Wagon 3dr
Its perfect for life on the farm and also brilliant for the weekly shop
Richard Hammond 110 2.4D XS SW 5dr
Worst in class Land Rover Discovery
The car is fantastic in theory, but the practicalities of owning a Discovery make buying one a bad and costly mistake.
Glen Board 2.7 TDV6 SE Auto