Used test: BMW 3 Series vs Mercedes-Benz C-Class
Buying a five-year-old executive saloon gets you lots of car for your money – but which is the better bet: a BMW 3 Series or a Mercedes C-Class?...
What will they cost?
Both cars will cost you roughly the same to buy; the Mercedes C-Class might be a smidge pricier, but in real terms the difference in price between the two cars is minimal.
It is worth keeping in mind that the BMW 3 Series is more ubiquitous, so the chances are it’ll be a little easier to find. That said, if you want an automatic gearbox, as fitted to our test cars, that changes, because the majority of 3 Series are manual.
The 3 Series is the cheaper of the two cars to fuel, too, with an official average figure of 62.8mpg; the C-Class is a little way off, its 58.9mpg figure suggesting there’ll be a noticeable difference between the two cars' real-world economy.
There’s a big difference between the tax costs of the two cars, too. The 3 Series' lower emissions mean it slips into tax band C, so it’ll cost £30 a year at current rates. However, the C-Class has to make do with tax band D – and as a result, its annual tax rate is £115.
There’s more bad news for C-Class owners when it comes to servicing costs, because here, too, the 3 Series is cheaper. Furthermore, aftermarket maintenance and repairs also look to be a little more cost-effective on the 3 Series.
As if that weren’t enough, the 3 Series has a better reliability record than the C-Class. In our most recent reliability survey, the 3 Series achieved a score of 82.5% – significantly better than the C-Class’s 69.7% rating.
Best executive cars 2024 – tested, rated and those to avoid
Great executive cars are comfortable, classy and well equipped, yet also cheap to run. Here we name the best 10 executive cars on sale in the UK – plus one we recommend avoiding