FOR The A5's engines are terrific, and the car has the comfort, quality and class to maintain Audi's reputation.

AGAINST It's claustrophobic in rear, and it's not as sporty as a BMW

FOR The A5 Sportback looks good, is as spacious as an A4 saloon and has added versatility. It has some fine engines, too, with the four-cylinder diesel particularly tempting to fleet users.

AGAINST It's neither sporty enough to be exciting to drive nor sufficiently comfortable to be truly relaxing. You won't like the off-set pedals.

FOR The A5 Cabriolet is everything an Audi drop-top should be – classy, refined and desirable. It's also surprisingly practical, cheaper than rival 3 Series Convertible models and has a strong engine range

AGAINST It's competent rather than entertaining to drive, with a firm ride and rather rubbery steering. The extra insulation of the acoustic hood costs extra for all but S line models.