FOR The Alfa 159 is an attractive car with a large, comfortable cabin and plenty of equipment, all at prices that undercut the usual German suspects

AGAINST The 159 isn’t brilliant to drive compared with, say, a BMW 3 Series and resale values are weak. Alfa Romeo also struggles with reliability and customer service.

FOR The 159 is a handsome car and cossets passengers with a comfortable ride. Prices undercut German rivals' and all versions are well equipped.

AGAINST The 159 isn't as sharp a drive as the BMW 3 Series and the cabin isn't as appealing as the exterior. High contract hire rates and poor residual values limit appeal, while boot is fairly useless for an estate.