FOR Practical; desirable; good to drive

AGAINST More expensive than rivals

FOR The VW Golf is refined and comfortable, but it's still fun to drive. The cabin is classy and practical, and every car gets lots of safety kit. Resale values are strong.

AGAINST Entry-level engines are underpowered, while the styling is too conservative for some.

FOR The Mk IV Golf has superb diesels, a classy cabin and strong residuals

AGAINST Costly to buy and the handling is stodgy

FOR It has all the class of the Golf and more room

AGAINST It's heavier than the Golf but is no more powerful

FOR Solidly built; excellent image

AGAINST Doesn’t handle very well; only average boot space