FOR The Grand Scenic is a compact MPV with reasonable room in all three rows (if you’re prepared to compromise in each of them). Quality is strong, too, while equipment levels are decent and it's good to drive.

AGAINST The Grand Scenic's middle row of seats don’t fold into the floor, limiting practicality. They’re heavy and awkward to remove and refit, too. The ride is a little firm and rear visibility when parking isn’t great.

FOR The Scenic is a spacious five-seat MPV with a swanky cabin and a big, well-shaped boot. It’s good to drive and refined, and running costs shouldn’t break the bank

AGAINST The rear seats don’t fold into the floor, limiting practicality. They’re heavy and awkward to remove and refit, too. Renault’s reliability record needs to improve