Alternatives

Used BMW 5 Series (03 - 11) review

(2003 - 2011)
BMW 5 Series (03 - 11)
Review continues below...

What alternatives should I consider to a used BMW 5 Series saloon?

If you value a sporty drive, then the Jaguar XF is worth considering, because it feels even sharper than the 5 Series. Just don’t expect it to be as fuel efficient or practical.

Alternatively, if comfort is your top priority, look no further than the Mercedes E-Class. It glides over bumps – as long as you avoid models with the optional sports suspension – and like the 5 Series is more practical than the XF. The biggest problem with the E-Class is its four-cylinder diesel engines, because they’re noisy and send a lot of vibration into the car's interior.

The engines in another rival, the Audi A6, are much smoother, and while the A6 can’t match the handling of the 5 Series or XF, or the ride comfort of the E-Class, it has the classiest interior of the lot.

For all the latest reviews, advice and new car deals, sign up to the What Car? newsletter here

What alternatives should I consider to a used BMW 5 Series saloon?

 

BMW 5 Series (03 - 11)
open the gallery9 Images

Verdict

This BMW 5 Series dominated the executive car class for most of its life, and it remains similarly appealing as a used buy.

  • Fun handling
  • Spacious and classy interior
  • Frugal diesel engines
  • Premium image
  • Firm ride on M Sport suspension
  • Some reliability issues
  • Looks aren’t to all tastes