New Renault Grand Scenic vs Citroen Grand C4 Picasso vs Volkswagen Touran

Renault has upped the MPV stakes with its stylish new Grand Scรฉnic seven-seater. Is it enough to defeat our current MPV of the Year, the Touran, or the revamped Grand C4 Picasso?

Words By What Car? team

Need a valuation?

Obtain a FREE used car valuation for any vehicle.


New Citroรซn Grand C4 Picasso vs Renault Grand Scรฉnic vs Volkswagen Touran

The contenders

Citroรซn Grand C4 Picasso 1.6 HDi 120 Feel

List price ยฃ24,990

Target Price ยฃ20,972

Has a recent facelift propelled the Grand C4 Picasso back to the top of the MPV class?

Renault Grand Scรฉnic 1.6 dCi 130 Dynamique Nav

List price ยฃ26,945

Target Price ยฃ26,420

Bold, SUV-inspired looks are aimed at setting the new Grand Scรฉnic apart from the plainer opposition

Volkswagen Touran 1.6 TDI 115 SE

List price ยฃ25,785

Target Price ยฃ21,136

Fresh from winning our MPV of the Year award for the second year in a row, the Touran will be hard to beat.

Let's be honest: a seven-seat MPV is the kind of car that you need rather than desire. The trouble for their makers is that there are now other options (think SUVs) that are almost as practical, but with far more kerbside appeal.

Renault has acknowledged this by being more than a little brave with its new Grand Scรฉnic. Rather than building another practical but unexciting box, it used a striking concept car as inspiration and produced a distinctive design that blends bold shapes with SUV styling cues.

To see if itโ€™s more than just a pretty face, weโ€™ve put it up against our current favourite MPV, the Volkswagen Touran. It may look plain, but itโ€™s good to drive, has an economical diesel engine and is filled with practical touches. And with Citroรซn having just updated its Grand C4 Picasso, thatโ€™s also a strong contender for top spot.

What are they like to drive?

All three of our contenders have 1.6-litre diesel engines, but there are clear differences in how they perform. With the most power and the shortest gearing, the Grand Scรฉnic is the quickest by some way if you accelerate from low revs, regardless of which gear youโ€™re in.

If youโ€™re accelerating through the gears from a standstill, the Grand C4 Picasso is similarly quick, but only when you rev its engine hard. The Touranโ€™s less powerful engine makes it slowest by a significant margin, but itโ€™s still quick enough. Itโ€™s the Touran that weโ€™d rather be in if it we had to stop quickly, though. From 30mph, it stopped 1.0m sooner than the C4 and 1.3m before the Scรฉnic. This gap only increases at higher speeds.

The Touran also impresses in the way it corners. Its steering feels meatier than the too-light C4โ€™s and artificial-feeling Scรฉnicโ€™s, allowing you to place the Touranโ€™s nose confidently. Body lean is well contained in both the Touran and Scรฉnic, but the C4 sways around noticeably under hard cornering.

In wet and slippery conditions, we found the stability control systems of the C4 and Scรฉnic to be quite abrupt in their operation compared with the subtle interventions of the Touranโ€™s.

While we wouldnโ€™t call any of these cars fun to drive, the Touran is easily the most enjoyable on a twisty country road. This is partly down to its fairly firm suspension. You do feel imperfections in the road, but good damping means these are dealt with quickly enough to avoid any juddering.

The C4โ€™s soft springs make it comfier most of the time, but it sometimes crashes over potholes. The Scรฉnic doesnโ€™t ride bumps as badly as you might expect given its huge 20in alloy wheels, but itโ€™s still the firmest of our trio. All three cars come with a six-speed manual gearbox.

The C4 and Scรฉnic have vague shift actions that arenโ€™t particularly satisfying, especially compared with the precise gearshift in the Touran. The C4 and Touranโ€™s engines tested here are available with automatic gearboxes, but you have to go for the more powerful 1.6-litre or less potent 1.5-litre motor if you want a self-shifting Scรฉnic.

The Scรฉnic certainly has the gruffest-sounding engine, with the most clatter when idling and the coarsest sound when accelerating. The C4 is far smoother and quieter unless you really push it, and while the Touranโ€™s engine is a bit boomy, itโ€™s the quietest all-round cruiser.

Next >

Page 1 of 5