Porsche 911 Carrera S vs Jaguar F-Type R Coupe

The latest Porsche 911 Carrera S has a smaller engine that's bolstered by a turbo, while the Jaguar F-Type R CoupΓ© boasts a supercharged V8. But which is best?

Words ByWhat Car? team

Need a valuation?

Obtain a FREE used car valuation for any vehicle.


Jaguar F-Type front

What will they cost?

Although these sports cars have very similar price tags, Jaguar dealers are willing to negotiate, which means the F-Type CoupΓ© will cost you around Β£8250 less if you’re paying cash.

Our depreciation experts predict the Porsche 911 will hold on to its value for slightly longer, but not by enough to offset its higher servicing costs and the extra cash you’ll need to stump up to begin with. All things considered, the F-Type is likely to cost you marginally less to own over three years, but probably not by enough to influence your buying decision.

If you’re lucky enough to have these sports cars on your company car list the 911 is the much cheaper option. Its lower CO2 emissions qualify it for a cheaper band of benefit-in-kind tax, so as a 40% tax payer you’ll have to sacrifice around Β£4600 less of your salary over the next three years.
If you’re in the 45% bracket that difference rises to nearly Β£5200.

The F-Type is much more generously equipped, though. You get fully electric seats, cruise control, automatic xenon headlights and rain-sensing wipers, which add up to Β£3000 on the 911. Then again, Porsche throws in dual-zone climate control whereas Jaguar charges Β£350. Heated seats, front parking sensors and a reversing camera are optional on both.

< Previous | Next >

Page 3 of 4

Related Articles


Porsche 911

What Car? SaysRated 5 out of 5
Owners sayRated 5 out of 5

A fantastic sports car and one of the few you can live with every day. The Audi R8 might be more theatrical than the Turbo models, but the lower-end 911 models are world-class, and define the sports car category.