What Car? Car of the Year awards 2009 - Open-top

Article 10 of 18 See all
  • 16 categories of awards
  • All the winning models featured here
  • What Car? Car of the Year 2009 revealed
What we were looking for: People buy convertibles for those long summer days, but still have to live with them in winter. Our winner will be a joy to own in all weathers

The contenders
Best buy under £16,000
Mazda MX-5 1.8i
List price £15,420
Target Price £14,062
Best web price £13,148 (www.carfile.net)

Best buy £16,000 – £30,000
Volkswagen Eos 2.0 TSI Sport
List price £23,720
Target Price £21,963
Best web price £21,079 (autobytel.co.uk)

Best buy over £30,000
Porsche Boxster S
List price £39,599
Target Price £39,599
Best web price na

The winner is…
Volkswagen Eos 2.0 TSI Sport
List price £23,720
Target Price £21,963

True to Volkswagen's 'people's-car' philosophy, the Eos is an open-top that anyone can enjoy.

The Eos has won this award for the past two years, and it now completes the hat trick. While the Porsche Boxster S is a sensational sports car, and the Mazda MX-5 offers fresh-air fun at a low price, neither can compete with the Volkswagen's combination of driving pleasure, everyday practicality and affordability. For starters, the Eos is actually a realistic option for families because you get four proper seats. Its boot is also big enough to take small cases when the roof is folded, and much bigger loads when it's not, plus there's useful stowage space in the cabin.

That cabin is a great place to while away the miles, too. The plastics and fittings have a quality feel to them and all of the controls are simple to use. There's even a sliding glass sunroof that gives a welcome sense of airiness on those grim winter days.

It's all good
Plenty of convertibles drive well enough with the roof in place, only for things to go wobbly once it's stowed — but the Eos bucks this trend.

While it isn't totally immune from body shake, there's a suppleness to its ride that most rivals can't get close to. Even our favoured Sport model, which comes on slightly lowered and firmed-up suspension, makes light work of any potholes and speed bumps.

The Eos is equally soothing on the motorway by feeling extremely stable, but it can still mix it with the best on country roads. There's little body roll and plenty of feel through the steering wheel, while the grip on offer would put a piece of week-old chewing gum to shame.

To add to the fun, our pick of the range is hot hatch-quick. Then again, this is hardly surprising because it uses the 2.0-litre turbocharged engine from the previous Golf GTI. This peach of an engine produces 197bhp and 207lb ft of muscle, which helps the Eos effortlessly leap forward when you flex your right foot.

Refinement is another of the car's many strengths. That folding metal roof is better at shutting out wind noise than a soft-top, and there's little buffeting in the cabin when the roof is stowed.

Value for money
There are cheaper coupe-cabriolets around, including lesser versions of the Eos, but you get more than what you pay for with the 2.0 TSI Sport. In addition, the Eos is a relatively safe place to invest your cash, because the residuals are comparatively strong.

Volkswagen's convertible is a cracking car to buy, then, as well as a hoot to own. What more could you ask for?

Click image above to enlarge

What Car? Car of the Year awards 2009 - Performance car


Free car valuations