Most reliable brands for older cars - and the least

Most older cars won't have a manufacturer warranty to help out if they go wrong, so you'll need to pick a dependable brand. We reveal the most and least reliable.....

Some people remain loyal to one car brand throughout their driving life.

Most and least reliable brands for older cars header

One important factor behind this is reliability. If you're on your sixth Mini and they've all performed faultlessly, you're likely to be happy to get another, but if your cars have spent more time in the garage than on the road, you're probably thinking about switching to another make as soon as you can.

To save you from finding out the hard way which brands are the most – and least –dependable, we asked the owners of nearly 13,000 cars to tell us if their vehicles had gone wrong in the past year. We classified the faults into 14 groups: air-con, battery, bodywork, brakes, engine, engine electrics, exhaust, fuel system, gearbox/clutch, infotainment/sat-nav, interior trim, non-engine electrics, steering and suspension.

For each fault, we asked the owner to tell us how much the car cost to repair and how long it took to fix, and we used the information to work out a unique reliability rating for each model. The result is real-life reliability data on 175 models from 31 car brands. Here we list brand reliability data for cars aged between six and 20 years old - an age range where many cars become affordable by many people, useful in these uncertain times when plenty of people need some wheels.

Slideshow story - please click the right-hand arrow above to continue, or simply scroll down if you’re reading on your mobile 

10. Volvo

Volvo XC90

What Car? Reliability rating 84.7%

Volvo models are generally a good choice if you're after a solidly built and dependable secondhand car. The V40 (2012-2019) is the second highest achieving older family car, with a rating of 95.6%, while the XC90 (2002-2015) is the third best luxury SUV, with a 75.0% score. 

9. Subaru

2015 Subaru Forester 2.0d XC Premium review

What Car? Reliability rating 87.8%

Although the sample sizes at model level were too small for us to be able to report on specific Subarus, the brand as a whole posted a strong score. Its two top performers were the Outback (2015-present) and Forester (2013-present). 

8. Hyundai

Hyundai i10 2009 front

What Car? Reliability rating 89.2%

The Hyundai i10 (2008-2013) is advancing into old age now, but it's still proving rugged, posting a score of 89.0%. The iX20 (2012-2019) looks like a sound secondhand buy, with a reliability rating of 94.6%, and the i30 hatchback (2012-2017) isn't far behind on 81.6%.

7. Seat

Seat Leon ST

What Car? Reliability rating 90.7%

The Seat Leon (2013-2020) is not only an affordable used buy, it's also an extremely reliable option, especially if you get a diesel-engined model. It gained a 98.7% rating and owners said the only problem area was the braking system. The smaller Ibiza (2008-2017) isn't as robust, but a score of 82.0% for such an old model is still impressive. 

6. Mitsubishi

Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV side

What Car? Reliability rating 91.2%

The Outlander plug-in hybrid (2014-present) is the star of the Mitsubishi line-up, posting a creditable score of 87.3%. We don't have enough examples to give the ASX (2010-present) a rating, but that looks like a sound secondhand buy as well.

5. Honda

Honda CR-V

What Car? Reliability rating 91.6%

Three models stand out as high-achievers for Honda: the Jazz (2008-2015) is the second most reliable small car, the Civic (2012-2017) is the second best family-sized car, and the CR-V (2012-2018) is the best large SUV. The CR-V shares its accolade with Toyota's RAV4 – both gained a reliability rating of 100% because owners told us they hadn't suffered a single fault in the previous year.

4. Suzuki

Suzuki Swift Sport

What Car? Reliability rating 91.9%

The Swift (2010-2017) is one of the most dependable small cars, with a rating of 95.1%, and although we don't have enough examples to create ratings for them, the SX4 S-Cross (2013-present) and Vitara (2015-present) also appear to be extremely dependable.

3. Toyota

Toyota RAV4

What Car? Reliability rating 92.2%

The recently replaced RAV4 (2013-2019) storms ahead, with a reliability rating of 100%, and the previous RAV4 (2006-2012) isn't far behind on 95.7%. The diminutive Yaris Hybrid (2011-2020) also proved fault-free, scoring a perfect 100% and demonstrating the durability of Toyota's hybrid technology.

2. Kia

Used Kia Picanto Hatchback 11-17

What Car? Reliability rating 92.7%

With a reliability rating of 98.5%, the Picanto (2011-2017) is the shining star of Kia's older car line-up. Owners told us the only problem area was the battery. The larger Ceed (2012-2018) is also looking durable, gaining a score of 94.2%.

1. Lexus

Lexus IS

What Car? Reliability rating 96.0%

The fact that most Lexus models are hybrids, and therefore more complex than conventionally-engined cars, makes its extremely high level of dependability even more impressive. The CT (2011-present) is the second highest scoring model in the electric/hybrid class with 98.0%, and the IS (2013-present) is right behind it with 97.6%.  

So that's the best brands - what about the least reliable brands for older cars? Read on:

3. Renault

Used Renault Grand Scenic 09-16

What Car? Reliability rating 72.6%

No single model stands out as the poorest performer in the Renault range, but Scenic (2009-2016) owners told us 46% of their cars had suffered a fault and Megane (2008-2016) owners said 57% had gone wrong.  

2. Nissan

Nissan Qashqai front cornering - 63-plate car

What Car? Reliability rating 70.4%

The Qashqai is the main reason Nissan sits second from bottom in the brand table. The 2007-2013 Qashqai scored a lowly 45.6% reliability rating, and the newer Qashqai (2014-2020) scored only marginally better on 46.3%, with 38% of owners reporting an issue with their car. 

1. Land Rover

Used Land Rover Discovery front corner

What Car? Reliability rating 66.3%

Land Rover takes the wooden spoon as the least reliable brand for older cars. The Discovery Sport (2014-present) is the least dependable large SUV, with a score of 51.4%, after 43% of owners reported at least one fault on their car. The Discovery (2004-2017) is the third worst luxury SUV, with a rating of 45.7% and a fault rate of 52%.

Related cars

Spinner