Used test: Ford Fiesta ST vs Mini Cooper S

A used Mini Cooper S has always been a sophisticated hot hatch, but can the raucous charms of Ford’s hottest Fiesta ST be enough to tempt you?...

Author Avatar
What Car? team
03 January 2019

Used Ford Fiesta ST vs Mini Cooper S

What will they cost?

Despite both cars costing similar money, the Mini manages to offer cheaper insurance and servicing costs. A transferable five-year service pack could be ordered when the Mini was new, and also has the option of being extended for a further three years for a reasonable amount of money. Surprisingly, though, the Fiesta is more frugal in real-world driving, besting the Mini by slightly more than two mpg. You will have to pay £20 per year in road tax for the Fiesta, however, due to its worse on paper fuel economy. 

Used Ford Fiesta ST vs Mini Cooper S

The Fiesta fights back with a five-star Euro NCAP safety rating compared with the Mini’s four-star rating, although the Mini was tested under a newer, more stringent system.

Both cars come well equipped as standard, with climate control (dual-zone in the Fiesta), a DAB radio, steering wheel-mounted controls, satellite navigation, sports seats, cruise control and automatic lights and wipers. The Mini adds LED headlights and an adjustable boot floor to that tally.