Used test: Renault Twingo Renault Sport vs Fiat 500 Abarth vs Mitsubishi Colt Ralliart
With a new, quicker Renault Twingo around the corner, we find out whether now's the time to buy a used Twingo Renault Sport, or if you'd be better off with one of its rivals...
Fiat 500 1.4 T-Jet Abarth
List price when new £13,600
Price today £5000-£15,000
Available from 2009-2017
Cuddly to bloodcurdling in one move. The 500 Abarth looks to have it all
Mitsubishi Colt 1.5T Ralliart
List price when new £12,249
Price today £3,500-£6500
Available from 2009-2013
The understated choice, but fire it up and there’s nothing demure about it
Renault Twingo 1.6 Renault Sport 133 Cup
List price when new £12,220
Price today £2000-£6500
Available from 2008-2013
Generations of Renault hot hatches in its DNA suggest the Twingo will be an absolute hoot
The arrival of the new Renault Twingo GT next week has enthusiasts of small, fun hatchbacks mouths' watering. The combination of more power and a rear-engined, rear-wheel-drive powertrain is an exciting one, and we will, of course, be bringing you our full first drive of the new car as soon as we’ve slipped behind the wheel.
You don’t have to wait for the GT to arrive in showrooms to partake of a fun, pocket-sized hatchback with a Renault badge on it, though. The previous-generation Twingo Renault Sport has shed a huge amount of its value and now looks like a terrific bargain as a used buy.
It doesn’t have the market all to itself, mind you. Fiat 500's Abarth has made a name for itself as the fashionable hot hatch of choice, with looks that successfully juxtapose cuddliness with aggression and the promise of plenty of power from a 1.4-litre turbo engine. Ballistic performance is on offer from higher-performance versions, but here we’re sampling the simplest Abarth, with a 133bhp engine that lines up neatly against the Twingo’s 131bhp unit.
There is one more contender to consider, though, and it’s one you probably haven’t heard of. The Mitsubishi Colt Ralliart was launched at around the same time as the 500, yet its fame is a fraction of its Italian rival’s. That’s probably because it wasn’t much to look at, but the 147bhp on offer from its 1.5-litre turbo engine means you write it off at your peril.
What are they like to drive?
Any hot hatch, even a fun-sized one like these three, should give you a hefty kick in the pants every time you prod the throttle. The Colt gives you the biggest shoeing, thanks to its turbocharged 1.5-litre engine. It’s quick to deliver its power, flying out of the blocks faster than a scalded Usain Bolt, and it doesn’t stop sprinting until it hits 125mph.
The 500 makes do with a little less power, but when you press its dashboard-mounted Sport button it has almost as much pull as the Colt. True, the 500 doesn’t get off the line as cleanly because its front wheels scrabble for tractio. But once up and running, acceleration feels just as eager, although an inaccurate gearshift can scupper your progress.
The Twingo’s engine has no turbocharger, so despite having the largest capacity here, at 1.6 litres, it’s down on power and pull. It needs lots of revs to get going, too, so it’s less flexible than the others. At high revs, though, there’s easily enough pace to keep you smiling.
If you really want to make the Twingo come alive, stick it on a winding road. The Cup’s lowered, stiffened suspension means corners are tackled with virtually zero body lean, and it darts from corner to corner crisply and precisely.
The steering is quick, accurate and full of feel – push the front tyres beyond their lofty limits and you’ll know instantly.
There’s plenty of fun to be had in the 500, too. It behaves predictably in corners, and although the steering is short of feedback it gets weightier in Sport mode. Even so, the 500 lacks the agility and composure of the Twingo.
The Colt’s handling is even further adrift. Even though the suspension is tuned to reduce body roll, it still lurches around more than the others. The steering feels odd, too, because the weighting is inconsistent.
All three stiffly-sprung contenders jostle you around. The Colt is the most forgiving, while the Twingo’s ride has the sharpest edge.
The Twingo is the noisiest, with that rev-hungry engine. Still, none of these cars is so loud that your eardrums beg for mercy, so just crank up the tunes and ignore it.
The best plug-in hybrid cars in 2021
Plug-in hybrids can reduce fuel consumption to an absolute minimum, but which models are the best all-rounders and which should you avoid?...
Fiat 500 Convertible long-term test review
Is an electric convertible a viable proposition or too much of a compromise? We're finding out by living with the Fiat 500 Convertible