In partnership with Autotrader
Used test: BMW X2 vs Volvo XC40 interiors
You can save more than £10,000 on either of these prestige family SUVs by buying used, but which car should you choose? We have the answer...
Driving position, visibility, build quality, practicality
Remember we said that the BMW X2 drives more like a sporty hatchback than a proper SUV? Well, that’s how it feels from behind the wheel too. Yes, it has a slightly raised ride height and the option of jacking the seat right up, but the only people you tower over are those driving sports cars.
The Volvo XC40 is somewhat different. It's taller, and the seats are mounted much higher up, giving you a towering view of the road. You won’t be fooled into thinking you’re in a Range Rover but you at least feel as though you’re in a proper SUV.
The X2’s low stance isn't the only black mark against it. Its sloping roof, chunky rear pillars and tiny rear screen make reversing tricky, even with standard rear parking sensors. A rear-view camera was optional from new, but – unlike with the XC40 – there was no 360-degree camera on the options list.
The XC40 scores for having much bigger windows and slimmer rear pillars, and it has rear sensors as standard. When night falls, you’ll be pleased to find that both cars have powerful LED headlights.
The low-slung X2 does without electric seat and lumbar adjustment, but most of our testers were able to find a reasonably comfortable driving position. That said, our shortest testers found the adjustable under-thigh support didn’t go in far enough, leaving the seat base digging into the backs of their knees. There are no such issues in the XC40 – its electrically-adjustable seat is very comfy.
The X2 isn’t perfect, but you won’t hear us grumbling about how its interior looks and feels. It’s clearly based on the X1’s – which is no bad thing – but BMW has introduced some even more expensive-looking trims, a gear selector that looks like it’s from the BMW 5 Series and contrasting stitching on the dashboard. There are also plenty of soft-touch plastics and some seriously high-quality switches and stalks. It’s disappointing that the X2 doesn’t have leather seats as standard, though.
As good as the X2 is, the XC40 runs it exceedingly close. There are a few more hard plastics inside and some of the switches aren’t quite as precise, but we’re splitting hairs – and many will prefer the XC40’s more minimalist interior design.
We doubt anyone will have any issues with the space in the front of these two cars. Both are within a couple of centimetres of each other for shoulder room, no one is likely to find their head brushing the ceiling and the front seats slide back a long way to accommodate longer legs. The XC40 we tested had the least front head room by some margin, but that was largely down to the presence of the optional panoramic sunroof.
Passengers in the back will notice more of a difference between the two models. The X2’s roofline makes it the worst for rear head room, and rear leg room isn’t wonderful either. The XC40 is the best for head and leg room, and has the widest rear seat area.
The X2 has the least storage for your odds and ends. There are a couple of cupholders in front of the gear selector, plus a tiny shelf. There's a shelf for your phone under the central armrest, and under that is another cubby with a USB port.
The Volvo XC40 has much bigger door pockets up front and there’s more space for oddments around the gear selector. Between the front seats is a bigger cubby that even has a removable bin with a spring-loaded lid. The rear door pockets are less impressive, but there are trays between the outer rear seats and the doors.
The BMW X2 boot may look relatively small, but it has a huge underfloor storage area that can (just) swallow a couple of carry-on suitcases. The downside is that there’s a sizeable lip to contend with at its entrance, and there are no buttons or levers to fold the rear seats from the boot.
Even with a spare wheel fitted, the XC40’s boot can accommodate seven carry-on cases with ease. It has storage cubbies to stop your stuff rolling around, a low load lip, and the option of a pop-up divider to hang your shopping bags on. It’s easily the best boot here. Volvo did charge extra for a powered tailgate from new, though.
Best family SUVs 2023
Want practicality, class and an elevated driving position in a relatively compact and affordable package? These are the top 10 cars you should be looking at – and the ones that are best avoided
Volvo XC40 long-term test
The Volvo XC40 saw off all comers to be named the 2018 What Car? Car of the Year. But were we as impressed when we lived with one every day?