How to buy your first car: insurance

Passing your driving test is a great achievement. Here’s how to build on that success by buying a safe, reliable car without breaking the bank...

How to buy your first car – insurance

It’s not just the cost of financing a car that young drivers and their parents have to worry about; insurance can be crushingly expensive. Although drivers under the age of 25 are likely to pay twice as much for car insurance than those over 50, premiums are lower than they have been due to a number of factors, including the impact of the coronavirus pandemic. According to, the average cost of comprehensive car insurance for a 19-year-old driver is £505, although those living in cities might pay more than this.

Any premium will be based on all sorts of variables, including the driver’s age, driving experience, postcode and so on. Clearly, there’s not a lot a teenager can do about their age and number of years on the road, but they can do something about the car they drive.

Cars are given an insurance grouping of 1-50. Thatcham Research decides which car fits into which group, taking into account a car’s performance, price, safety, security and the cost of repairing. The lower the insurance group number, the lower the insurance premium should be.

Government to investigate graduated driving licences for new drivers

Other ways to reduce premiums include limited-mileage policies. However, it’s important to be realistic when setting a mileage limit, because there are likely to be extra fees if it’s exceeded and your cover could be invalid if you exceed it but don't tell the insurer.

Setting a high excess (the amount the driver has to contribute to repairs in the event of a claim) is another option, but be sure the amount isn’t more than you’ll be able to afford if you have to pay out.

Another means of chipping away at the annual premium is to insure a second, responsible driver (say, a parent or an older sibling). Just be sure that it’s someone who will actually drive the car. And don’t be tempted to make a parent the main driver on a policy if the car is really the child's; this is known as ‘fronting’ and is considered insurance fraud.

Telematics or 'black box' insurance can also reduce a young driver’s premium. With these policies, the car is fitted with a black box to monitor when and how it is driven. Stick to the speed limit and drive smoothly and the cost of cover will come down after a while. But drive badly and your premium could rise. There are negatives, though, because some policies include night or mileage limits, and if you drive aggressively you could see your premiums rise beyond your initial quote.

How about all-in-one car and finance deals?

How to buy your first car – insurance

One way to get on top of buying a new car and insuring it in one go is to opt for a PCP scheme that also includes the cost of insurance in a single monthly payment.

Peugeot offers one called Just Add Fuel. It’s available to drivers as young as 18, as long as they have a telematics box fitted to monitor how the car is driven and report back to the insurer. As the name implies, the scheme not only covers the cost of insurance but also routine bills such as servicing. This simplicity clearly appeals to young drivers; 27% of Just Add Fuel customers are aged 18-24.

Monthly payments vary but, based on a low-risk address and a £500 deposit, Peugeot’s online finance calculator quoted us a monthly payment of £372 for an 18-year-old buying a Peugeot 108 1.0 Active 3dr on a 37-month deal, with an annual mileage limit of 6667 miles.

Peugeot 108

Specialist young driver insurer Marmalade also offers a car-and-insurance bundle called Fuel & Go. However, unlike Peugeot’s scheme, servicing costs aren’t covered. Deposits start from £500 and monthly payments can be as low as £202. 

As with the Peugeot scheme, Fuel & Go customers have a black box fitted to their car, but they aren’t tied to one car brand. Vehicles from 14 manufacturers are available, including the Fiat 500 and Ford Fiesta.

< Previous | Next: Choosing the best first car > 

Page 2 of 3