What Car? Personal Shopper: small car for £16,000
Our choice: buy used
Honestly, we thought the cracking Seat Ibiza was going to have this all sewn up, with its practical interior, peppy engine and enjoyable handling. And then the used Volkswagen Polo blew it clean out of the water.
The fact that you can get a barely used Polo, with its premium interior, long equipment list and our recommended 1.0-litre petrol engine for just under £13,000 is staggering. So much so, in fact, that it's our clear winner this time.
Our recommendation, then, is to buy used.
Want us to pick out your perfect car? Email whatcareditorial@haymarket.com with a photo of yourself, your budget, your current car, your age, your annual mileage and an idea of what you'd like from your next car. Or get in touch with us via Twitter, @whatcar
See our latest new car deals >
For all the latest reviews, advice and new car deals, sign up to the What Car? newsletter here