New Jaguar I-Pace vs Tesla Model S
The electric car market is amping up with the arrival of the Jaguar I-Pace SUV. Has the Tesla Model S finally met its match?...
Our verdict
If you read the September edition of What Car? magazine, you’ll have seen a different outcome in this very same test, with the Model S coming out on top. But a couple of things have changed since then.
First, Tesla’s pricing has increased, which has swung the finances in favour of the I-Pace – although the Model S does now come with a Premium Upgrades Package, which includes heated seats.
Second, the first I-Pace we tested was a pre-production model, and software tweaks made since then have endowed the car a much more impressive real-world range.
It’s an extremely close-run thing, but the I-Pace just clinches the win. It’s not quite as good to drive as the Model S, nor is it as practical, but for real-world range and ownership costs – two crucial areas for Electric car buyers – it has the Tesla beaten. It's more comfortable and classier inside, too.
However, the fact that this is such a close-run test shows how far ahead of its time the Model S was.
1st Jaguar I-Pace
Rated 5/5
For Plusher interior; superior range; better low-speed ride; better resale values
Against Not as practical; slower to charge
Read our full Jaguar I-Pace review
Find a great Jaguar I-Pace deal
2nd Tesla Model S
Rated 4/5
For More agile handling; massive boot; access to Tesla Superchargers
Against Mixed interior quality; woeful reliability record; pricey options
Read our full Tesla Model S review
Find a great Tesla Model S deal
Specifications: Jaguar I-Pace EV400 SE
Engine Two electric motors
List price £69,495
Target price £65,995
Battery size 90kWh
Peak power 394bhp
Peak torque 513lb ft
Gearbox Single-speed automatic
0-60mph 4.5sec
Top speed 124mph
Real range 253 miles
Cost of full charge £11.87
Electricity cost per mile 4.7p
Electricity cost per 12k miles £564
CO2 emissions 0g/km
Specifications: Tesla Model S 75D
Engine Two electric motors
List price £72,350
Target price £68,850
Battery size 75kWh
Peak power 362bhp
Peak torque 487lb ft
Gearbox Single-speed automatic
0-60mph 4.3sec
Top speed 140mph
Real range 204 miles
Cost of full charge £10.09
Electricity cost per mile 4.9p
Electricity cost per 12k miles £588
CO2 emissions 0g/km
Best estate cars 2024 – the top choices for luggage capacity
An estate car needs to be practical, but the best models are also comfortable, well equipped and affordable to run. Here we reveal our top 10 buys – and the estates to steer clear of