In partnership with Autotrader
Used test: Audi Q5 vs Porsche Macan vs Volvo XC60
The Audi Q5, Porsche Macan and Volvo XC60 large SUVs are all fantastic used buys, but which is best? We have the answer...
Audi Q5 2.0 TDI 190 quattro S Line
List price when new £41,085
Price today £27,000*
Available from 2017-present
Good to drive and relatively cheap to run, the Q5 is an excellent large SUV
Porsche Macan 3.0 S Diesel
List price when new £48,289
Price today £41,000*
Available from 2014-present
Proof that SUVs can handle well, but its sheer desirability makes it the most expensive car here
Volvo XC60 2.0 D4 R-Design AWD
List price when new £39,705
Price today £26,000*
Available from 2017-present
The XC60 is classy, roomy and well equipped, plus it's the cheapest used buy
*Price today is based on a 2018 model with average mileage and full service history, correct at time of writing
Let’s start by addressing the elephant in the room: how does the Porsche Macan fit into this used SUV triple test? The Audi Q5 and Volvo XC60 are easily comparable, but with its sporty performance and higher prices, the Macan seems less so.
It's a valid point, but while the buyer who both wants and needs a large SUV will be more than happy to put a premium-badged Audi or Volvo on their driveway they will be doubled up with delight by the prospect of putting a pukka Porsche there. For many, it'll be well worth digging a little deeper into those savings.
So it'll be interesting to see how much more the extra cash gets you, or whether it’s better to opt for one of the other two compelling contenders. All the cars are three years old, allowing for some good savings off their prices new. The Q5 and XC60 both have 2.0-litre diesel engines, while the Macan comes with a 3.0-litre diesel unit. All three get four-wheel drive and automatic gearboxes.
So, which used large SUV is the best buy?
Performance, ride, handling, refinement
If you covet performance, the Macan is the one for you. Cars equipped with the optional-from-new Sport Chrono pack have launch control, triggering 255bhp, while its two rivals have 188bhp. The Macan storms off down the road and on to 60mph in just 5.9sec, with the Q5 taking 2.0sec longer and the XC60 another 0.6sec on top of that.
That’s not to say the Q5 and XC60 are slow – both provide perfectly respectable grunt and can pull you along ably – they're just not as brisk as the Macan.
The XC60 is the loudest in terms of wind noise. Its big door mirrors are great for seeing what’s behind, but they whip up quite a flurry at 70mph. Mind you, there’s less road noise than in the other two.
In the Q5, it takes the form of a high-pitched drone that, incidentally, was worse than in Q5s we’ve tested previously. The Macan creates a resonance on certain surfaces that’s audible as well as haptic, feeding through the steering.
All things considered, the Q5 provides the most peaceful environment at a steady 70mph, followed by the XC60 and the Macan. None of them is exactly taxing to drive a long distance in, though.
Ride quality is a mixed bag, with all three displaying strengths and weaknesses. Let’s start with the XC60. On adjustable air suspension (an optional extra from new), it conveys you across crests, dips and ripples with a suppleness the other two cars can’t muster. It’s best on the motorway, soothing you along, while the other two, particularly the Macan, gently jiggle you.
Marvellous, you think, until the XC60 strikes something sharp-edged, such as a pothole. Then it jars you abruptly. If you traverse a string of such imperfections in quick succession, you feel a shimmy through the car’s body for good measure.
On its adaptive air suspension, which came as an optional extra from new, the Macan is a different kettle of fish. Even in its softest mode, you grasp immediately that it’s tauter and firmer. While the XC60 needs time to settle after a speed bump, the Macan controls its heft more quickly, and is less prone to crashing over jagged imperfections. That slight motorway fidget aside, it’s a good compromise.
The Q5 slots somewhere in between. Although as standard it gets what Audi calls Comfort Dynamic suspension, which is a bit softer, our car had the stiffer Sport suspension – a no-cost option when new. It produces the most background suspension noise and is marginally less compliant than the Macan, although it's less prone to thumping over broken roads than the XC60. We know, though, that the non-standard air suspension gives the Q5 a sublime, class-leading ride.
The Q5 is also pretty decent in the corners. Overall grip is good, the nose turns in keenly and the car changes direction crisply. The firm brake pedal is reassuring, too. Our only gripe is the steering – it’s accurate, but it's a touch light initially before becoming overly heavy with a quarter of a turn of lock on.
If the Q5 is good to drive, the Macan is brilliant by SUV standards. You’ll be amazed how such a heavy car darts into corners and shows great stability afterwards. The steering is weighty but consistent, nurturing your trust that the tyres will grip. Put simply, if you want an SUV that’s as close as possible to a sports car, the Macan is just the ticket.
The XC60 is the least impressive in corners. At anything more than a moderate pace, it lurches around, and while the steering feels weighty in the centre, keeping you tracking true down a motorway, it’s too light through corners to give you any real feedback or confidence. That does make the XC60 the easiest to manage around town, though.
Page 1 of 4
Best 7-seat cars 2022
Whether you're looking for a part-time seven-seater or a car to carry that many people on a regular basis, check out which ones to go for – and which to avoid
Audi Q5 long-term test
This second-generation Audi Q5 has long been a favourite in the large SUV class, but has a recent facelift made it even better? We're living with one to find out
New Land Rover Discovery Sport & Mercedes GLC vs Audi Q5
The Land Rover Discovery Sport lost its seat to the Audi Q5 in the 2017 election of posh large SUVs. Can it regain its place with major changes of policy? A previous outsider with a similar plan will only make that harder...