WhatCarAwards banner - desktop

In association with MotorEasy

Car of the Year Awards 2023: Convertible of the Year

A good convertible should obviously offer wind-in-the-hair thrills, but, we’re looking for a car that also delivers an enjoyable drive and a four-seat interior that makes you feel special...

WINNER: Convertible of the Year

BMW 4 Series Convertible 420i M Sport (Pro Pack)

Car of the Year 2023 main logo

The best convertible should allow its driver to enjoy open-top thrills when the weather permits, but still be comfortable and engaging on those occasions when the sun isn’t playing ball. Thankfully, the BMW 4 Series Convertible is truly a car for all seasons.

Sharing its underpinnings with the class-leading BMW 4 Series Coupé, the drop-top is far more than just a boulevard cruiser. With terrifically precise steering and little of the body flex that can afflict some convertibles along uneven roads, it feels more agile and pleasurable to drive than four-seat rivals such as the Ford Mustang Convertible and Mercedes C-Class Cabriolet. And when it’s equipped with the adaptive suspension that comes as part of the highly recommended
M Sport Pro Pack, you can stiffen up or soften the ride to suit the type of driving you’re doing, the 4 Series Convertible being suitably cosseting when you select Comfort mode.

Convertible of the Year 2023 - BMW 4 Series Convertible side

When the roof is up, the 4 Series does a fine job of keeping wind and road noise at bay at motorway speeds. And when it’s tucked away under its cover, you’re well protected from air turbulence around your head and body, while warm air can be directed around your neck from vents in the front seats.

Inside, the 4 Series is classier and more robust than the Mustang and C-Class, plus its infotainment system is slicker and easier to use on the move than any rival’s. Usability is another 4 Series strength, with more rear seat space (roof up) than most other four-seat drop- tops, plus a boot that’s capable of swallowing more than just a soft overnight bag or two.

Although the six-cylinder engines that power pricier versions are lovely things, our pick of the line-up is the entry-level 2.0-litre four-cylinder petrol, because it offers gutsy enough performance to meet most buyers’ needs while keeping running costs sensible.

Convertible of the Year 2023 - BMW 4 Series Convertible interior

The 4 Series Convertible is something of a bargain next to its rivals, too. Not only is its starting price lower than those of the Mustang and C-Class, but it also comes loaded with luxuries such as heated leather seats and three-zone climate control.

Some drop-tops are in their element only in idyllic conditions – but the 4 Series Convertible isn’t one of them. With very few compromises, it can be used effortlessly all year round.

For all the latest reviews, advice and new car deals, sign up to the What Car? newsletter here

See all of our Car of the Year 2023 winners >>