In association with MotorEasy
Best and worst older cars for reliability: family SUVs
We name the most dependable (and most troublesome) used cars from six to 15 years old, based on owners’ experiences...
The most reliable family SUVs
1. BMW X1 (2015-present)
Reliability rating 97.8%
What went wrong? Exhaust 8%, non-engine electrics 8%
Only 15% of X1s had any troubles, and all cars could still be driven. All issues were resolved in less than a week and, best of all, even though the cars in our survey are out of the manufacturer’s new car warranty period, all remedial work was done at no expense to owners.
Owner comment: “It has taken me all over Europe safely and reliably, and the one major repair it needed was done for free.”
Save money on a new BMW X1 with What Car? >>
2. Kia Sportage diesel (2016-2021)
Reliability rating 97.6%
A mix of minor and major faults affected 17% of current diesel Sportages. The two most common issues were with the bodywork and suspension, with a small percentage of reports of steering-related problems. Kia’s seven-year warranty meant all cars were fixed for free, and 75% were sorted out in a day or less.
3. Kia Sportage (2010-2016)
Reliability rating 93.3%
The previous-generation Sportage is ageing well: trouble was reported with only 24% of cars. Problem areas included the air-con, bodywork, engine and non-engine electrics, the gearbox/clutch and suspension. That’s a long list, but an impressive 86% of faults were fixed for free and no bills topped £200.
Save money on a used Kia Sportage >>
The least reliable family SUVs
1. Range Rover Evoque (2011-2019)
Reliability rating 61.7%
What went wrong? Bodywork, 15% suspension 15%, battery 12%, gearbox/clutch 12%, air-con 10%, non-engine electrics 10%, brakes 7%, engine electrics 7%, interior trim 5%, sat-nav 5%, engine 2%, exhaust 2%, steering 2%
With a 44% fault rate and problems in nearly every category, owners of previous-generation Evoques can expect to be on first-name terms with repairers. Forty-six percent of faulty cars were out of action for more than a week, and the only good news is that 87% of work was done for free, with no bills exceeding £200.
Owner comment: “I’m disappointed with the poor reliability and quality of some major parts. Not what you’d expect from an expensive car.”
2. Nissan Qashqai diesel (2007-2013)
Reliability rating 63.4%
Diesel Qashqais are far more prone to faults than petrol ones, with 56% going wrong (versus 25%). Issues were widespread, but the most common were with the engine and brakes. It’s not all bad news, though – 54% of problems were resolved within a day and four out of five owners paid out less than £300.
3. Volkswagen Tiguan diesel (2007-2016)
Reliability rating 65.8%
The Tiguan fares poorly across the board. Thirty-eight percent of the cars we were told about suffered a fault that rendered a third of them undriveable for more than a week. More than half of repair bills exceeded £300, and 13% of owners paid out more than £1500.
Reliability of family SUVs aged six to 15 years old
|Rank||Make and model||Score|
|1.||BMW X1 2015-present||97.8%|
|2.||Kia Sportage diesel 2016-2021||97.6%|
|3.||Kia Sportage 2010-2016||93.3%|
|=4.||Hyundai Tucson 2015-present||91.1%|
|=4.||Mitsubishi ASX 2010-present||91.1%|
|6.||Audi Q3 diesel 2011-2018||90.7%|
|7.||Audi Q3 petrol 2011-2018||89.7%|
|8.||Mercedes GLA 2014-2020||84.7%|
|9.||Nissan Qashqai petrol 2007-2013||81.1%|
|10.||Nissan Qashqai diesel 2014-2021||75.2%|
|11.||Dacia Duster 2013-2018||74.1%|
|12.||Volkswagen Tiguan 2016-present||73.3%|
|13.||Nissan Qashqai petrol 2014-2021||69.1%|
|14.||Volkswagen Tiguan diesel 2007-2016||65.8%|
|15.||Nissan Qashqai diesel 2007-2013||63.4%|
|16.||Range Rover Evoque 2011-2019||61.7%|
Best family SUVs 2023
Want practicality, class and an elevated driving position in a relatively compact package? Then these are the top 10 cars you should be looking at – and the ones that are best avoided
Citroën C5 Aircross long-term test
Citroën's family SUV rival has been upgraded inside and under the skin. But what's it like to live with? We're finding out