New Mazda CX-5 & Ford Kuga vs Skoda Kodiaq
Mazda’s spacious and upmarket new CX-5 aims to reclaim the large SUV crown – but first it has to beat our reigning champ, the Skoda Kodiaq, and Ford’s updated Kuga...
Ford Kuga 2.0 TDCi 150 ST Line
List price £28,745
Target Price £25,036
Revised Kuga gets a nose job and an updated infotainment system. Officially the most frugal car here
Mazda CX-5 2.2 Skyactiv-D 150 Sport Nav
List price £28,695
Target Price £27,486
Stylish, brand new CX-5 comes with just about every luxury you can think of in Sport Nav trim
Skoda Kodiaq 2.0 TDI 150 SE DSG
List price £27,115
Target Price £27,115
Our Large SUV of the Year, but in five rather than seven-seat form. Only car here with an auto gearbox
Well, the answer to that particular conundrum was, for many years, the Mazda CX-5. Big, practical and surprisingly good fun to drive, it was the go-to choice for anyone more concerned about value for money than a posh badge. But then along came the Skoda Kodiaq. Even bigger, much classier inside and yet similarly good value, it made the CX-5 seem rather old-hat.
Not one to take defeat lying down, Mazda is back with an all-new CX-5 that promises to fix some of its predecessor’s flaws – a low-rent interior and noisy road manners – without a big price hike. But Skoda and Mazda aren’t the only ones in this fight; Ford’s recently revised Kuga costs about the same and betters both for fuel economy.
What are they like to drive?
We’ve lined up our trio in 148bhp diesel form and stuck with cheaper and more efficient front-wheel drive, although four-wheel-drive versions of all three cars are available if you’re worried about getting up that slippery driveway in winter. The CX-5 and Kuga have six-speed manual gearboxes, while the Kodiaq gets a seven-speed automatic as standard.
Given that all of our contenders weigh about the same, it’s hardly surprising that there’s barely anything in it for straight-line pace; all can whisk you from 0-60mph in around 9.5sec. However, they go about this in very different ways. The CX-5’s engine actually feels more like a turbocharged petrol than a diesel, pulling keenly from around 1100rpm and revving freely until well past 5500rpm.
The Kuga’s engine has a much narrower sweet spot; it doesn’t pull as eagerly at very low revs and starts to run out of puff at about 4000rpm, so you need to change gear more frequently. Mind you, the Kuga’s gearchange is lighter and more precise than the CX-5’s.
Obviously, you don’t have to change gear at all in the Kodiaq; just push the accelerator pedal and the car chooses the most suitable gear to call on. It makes good decisions and shifts smoothly the majority of the time, although progress is a bit jerky at very low speeds, especially when parking.
Ford’s line-up includes some of the best-handling cars in the world, but the Kuga isn’t one of them. Yes, it stays the most upright of our trio through tight turns (the standard sports suspension on ST Line trim helping), but it also feels the most nervous, its front tyres try to follow every little camber and its steering is far too keen to self-centre.
The Kodiaq leans more than the Kuga through corners, but it’s actually much more composed and predictable, and its steering gives you a better sense that you’re in control of the car. However, it’s the CX-5 that has the best steering of the three and is the most enjoyable to drive on a winding country road.
The relatively stiff suspension that helps the CX-5 to handle well doesn’t do much for ride comfort, though. It’s certainly the most jarring of our trio over sharp-edged bumps, although the Kuga jostles you around more over minor imperfections. The Kodiaq is not only the most supple around town but also wafts along in the most comfortable fashion at 70mph, although the CX-5 and Kuga aren’t at all fractious on the motorway